Selection Six was an excerpt from Lynn White (Jr.)’s lecture entitled “The Historical Roots of our Ecological Crisis”. His discussion revolved around the idea that Christianity (among other religions) was being used to exploit nature. His argument is that they all promote the dominance of man over nature and neglect to inform believers of man’s need for nature. He believes that it is in man’s feeling of rightfulness to dominance over nature that has lead to the destruction of the very things we need to exist. White then begins to give examples of where man has exploited nature for his own use with no regard of the destruction that he is causing. He poses that man should recognize the reliance that we all have on nature and to act to preserve it. He also avoids the idea of equality among nature and man because he feels that that will lead to nowhere; rather he suggests that we should reconsider our interpretations of religion and not use it towards the exploitation of nature. He suggests that we try to realize the importance of balance before it is too late.
Selection Four was from Aldo Leopold’s “A Sound County Almanac”. Aldo Leopold was an officer in the U.S. Forest Services in the 1920’s who, upon an epiphany, realizes the importance of every single thing in nature. This excerpt recalls the details leading to his epiphany wherein he sees the death of a Wolf, not for the first time, but for the first time where he realizes that what he did was not right. By seeing the light die in the Wolf’s eyes for the first time and seeing the deterioration of the mountain sides that were overcome by the overpopulation of deer from lack of wolves, he sees the error of mass killing a species and not understanding its role in nature. The rest of the excerpt is a part of Leopold’s explanation on what he believes ethics should encompass. He suggests that we should expand our views of ethics to “include soils, waters, plants, and animals, or collectively: the land…” (page 12 of Thomas Easton’s excerpt in Environmental Studies of Aldo Leopold’s: A sound Almanac).
Selection 26 was a piece called “Climate Change 2007: The Physical Science Basis” and was generated Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). It was a long piece that gave previous and current projections of climate change based on statistical analysis and extrapolation. The main idea was to outline the reasons for and effects of greenhouse gas emissions. One of the main ideas is that anthropogenic activities are the main reasons behind global warming and the increased rates of global warming.
More Profit with Less Carbon by Amory B. Lovins was a reading that outlined the benefits of energy conservation that has been highly skewed over the years. He opens with saying that a basic misunderstanding can skew an entire debate on climate change. The idea is that energy conservation and energy efficiency are mistakenly costly to pursue. When considering the benefits and costs to choosing energy efficient methods, the general public mistakenly accounts only for the immediate cost trade-offs; they do not consider the long term benefits of switching over. Lovins continues to prove his point in this reading by giving examples of different countries or institutions that are saving much more money than they have spend upon switching over to energy efficient methods. He also introduces the idea of an energy efficient system, rather than individual pieces that don’t work together. He argues that a system is much more practical and efficient in saving and reducing consumption and that the benefits are there for all of us to share. He raised this argument by example of his own 4,000 square foot home in Colorado. In terms of vehicle energy saving opportunities, he argues that we are in an age now with the technology that allows us to have lighter, more efficient cars, without compromising the crash-safety of our cars. Finally, Lovins closes with an introduction to the benefits of renewable energy.
Selection 16 on Reinventing the Energy System by Christopher Flavin and Seth Dunn discussed the implications of creating an energy system that both fits the needs of the twenty first century and practicality. He takes a look back at when we first switch from infinite to finite resources in Europe in the seventeenth century to make note that whatever route we decide to take must be taken with precaution. The reading also questions why we chose to go in the direction of using finite resources in the first place; showing the implications that it has on us now was we approach the peak level of such resources. He then goes on to list and explain the different breakthroughs that we have had in recent years (a bit more than the last century or so) such as LED lights, wind power, solar power, fuel-cells, etc. In the last part of the reading the author relates the patters of energy consumption and societal hierarchies claiming that it is strange that the wealthier populous who have the most opportunity to switch to energy efficient methods and savings are adversely the ones who consume and waste the most energy. Finally, he closes with stating that energy should not be taken lightly; instead, it should be valued as a detrimental part of our well being and should not be wasted and neglected.
The main idea behind Selection 28 is in the unsustainable population growth and the unsustainable practices of such a population. The author, Lester Brown, makes reference to how the economic effects of our bad habits went from affecting our local environments to becoming a world issue that everyone is responsible. It requires a shift in thinking that we have not yet achieved. He argues that agricultural changes will be the first sign of un-sustainability. As in, we will realize the destructive path we are on starting with rising food prices. AS it becomes harder and harder to reproduce or replenish our sources, our value of everyday food sources will rise; along with it, the economic price. This is also consequential to the loss of land and water to supply our growing numbers. Hence, he argues that sustainability is not just an agricultural problem anymore, but rather, a global problem. Changes in environment will affect the reproductive and replenishing processes of our resources (e.g. agricultural food, fisheries, water, etc.). The problem lies in balancing between stabilizing populations and climate.
Reflection
Selection 6 really focused my thoughts on anthropocentricism and how that affects everything around us. I mean the belief that man is important is not an issue to me; it is in the belief that man is important and nothing else is that is ridiculous. I really don’t like the fact that any fact or excerpt (say from the Bible as suggested by White) can be manipulated or interpreted to benefit one ideology.
What caught my attention in White’s excerpt is when he outlines the anthropocentricism around agriculture. I have always thought of agriculture as one of the most revolutionary changes that has happened to man. It has allowed for the growth and development of mankind and has allowed man the option of staying in one location instead of always migrating. I never really thought of it as a selfish means to our existence which neglects the existence of nature around it. It was quite an epiphany for me.
I was most excited to read selection 4; I was really interested in reading Aldo Leopold’s work ever since we were introduced to a quote of his in one of our lectures. I felt that he writes very eloquently and he allows me to envision the issues more personally. I enjoy the fact that he writes in first-person perspective and relates his own experiences to the reader. Personally, I think that it is pretty rare to both preach the issues and admit to the same faults. His story about seeing a Wolf die and lose its fire really touched me. It’s strange to hear a story like that and know that it is true story. I can’t imagine going from being trigger-happy to understanding the value of life in other beings.
One of the key messages that I picked up from this reading is in how we have put up so many barriers and middlemen in between ourselves and nature. I took note of this because I know that personally, I can feel a lot better about myself if I was not the one committing the “crime”; it doesn’t matter if I am a contributing factor because I don’t feel the impact of actually committing the “crime”. This theory is easily applicable to many aspects of life. When you are rich, you forget what it is like to be poor and you don’t care because it is not your fault. Just the same, anyone can hate the oil-sands and yet we don’t take precautions to reduce and eliminate our uses. I realized in class when we were given the task of discussing the issues and possible solutions for our problem of “Peak Oil”. It was really easy for our group to point out the issues and to point fingers as to where the issue stems from but when we tried to discuss the possible solutions, we couldn’t think of any. We also all agreed that we were guilty of some of the issues we pointed out too. It really just comes to show how difficult it is to change perspectives and old habits.
It’s crazy how the theory of global warming was materialized over a century ago when sciences were just starting to evolve. When reading selection 26, I have to admit, that was the most interesting fact that I read. The reading was really informative as it consisted entirely of statistics and historical mappings of greenhouse emissions and causes but it didn’t offer me any new perspectives on the issues. Like I said before, the issues are fairly outlined and detailed, but it is in the solutions where we seem to lag. This piece did not offer me any new feelings towards global warming and any other environmental issues but rather, it just reinstates the obvious problems. I didn’t like how a lot of the information was also theoretical. The emphasis that was put on the word “likely” did not impress me. I understand that the establishment of a real cause-and-effect is highly unlikely but the emphasis put on such a point to be politically correct really does draw away from the issues; it almost makes me feel that I shouldn’t be believing these facts if the presenters themselves are uncertain of its truth (regardless of how close to the truth their predictions are). The issues were also not related very well to their effects. Global warming due to increased emissions in the atmosphere does not make me feel the immediate need to change. I did not understand that the melting of the ice caps will mean fewer habitats for other species which can force them to encroach upon human-inhabited land. I did not feel that melting of the ice sheets are adding to the problem of polar bear extinction. I did not feel that the warming of ocean waters is creating a loss in many oceanic species which also gives way to issues with our own consumption. In general, I did not feel that being slammed with information and foreboding messages of what generally could be was moving. It was very generic and repetitive.
Selection 15 which discussed the benefits of reducing our energy consumption and carbon emissions was a great piece. It provided many examples of small changes that could be done to achieve energy efficiency. It was most enjoyable when the author brings in his own home as an example of switching over to more energy efficient methods; using a lot of impressive exact figures to show his point. I really enjoy it when I read a piece that speaks not only about the issues but what we can do about it. This reading really gives readers a hope of changing the exponentially increasing problem of carbon emissions and use of finite resources. The piece was really easy to read and it engages the reader to think about their own consumptions. The author mentioned that five percent of the U.S. energy that is lost is from powering appliances and computers that are already off and made it personal for me; I felt that there was something right there that I could immediately do. I don’t know what it was about the piece exactly that made me feel this way because there are plenty of other arguments that relay a similar message. I guess it’s true regarding our desires for fortune; relating the benefits to the readers in monetary forms can really drive home the point.
Flavin and Dunn make a valid point in their piece: why did we choose to go in the path of a finite resource? Why didn’t we consider the consequences of choosing such a path? Was it because of the scientific breakthroughs and technology at the time that chose our paths for us as they have mentioned? Or is it because no one cares to think about issues that are too far down to their own time? I was really interested in the parts where the authors mentioned the technological advances that we have made already. In particular, I was really interested in their segment regarding fuel-cells. I never realized that we still have issues with efficiently separating hydrogen. I definitely feel strongly about this alternative resource; I think that we are definitely close to perfecting something that is highly beneficial to our health, economy, and environment.
Sustainability of our every growing population has been a major concern for many years. It is crucial that we understand the need for sustainable practices to meet our consumption needs. With a population that is exponentially growing, any bad habits can lead to detrimental consequences. I found Selection 26 to be thought provoking in that it connects the issues with bad agricultural habits to the bad habits that we, as a species, all have. Hearing about how close we are to using up our last bit of fresh water supply and crop-able land is a scary thought to me. It always makes me think of snippets from post-apocalyptic movies wherein the war is not for oil or territory, but for water. Water is the most basic of our needs and yet it is the most important. If we don’t take action to preserve it, how will we be able to secure a future for our descendents?
Blog Reflections (Classroom topics)
Where do your Environmental Ethics lie? Anthropocentric, biocentric, or ecocentric?
I think to say that my beliefs in environmental ethics lies within one area would to filter out a lot of real dilemmas. In honest truth, I would say that I am more biocentric; I am an animal lover and I believe in the humane treatment of all animals (bold statement, I know). This is a new area for me and I am slowly taking steps towards defending that statement. I also am not going to lie and say I like bugs and or creepy crawlies; I don’t. But I do understand the importance of their roles in nature. Although having diversity in flora also means that there would be more creepies, I would not change it. When I took a guided hike in one of the rain forests in Costa Rica, we were fortunate enough to be introduced to an area that has not been fully exploited by tourism yet. The diversity in that forest is amazing. We were shown things that we usually wouldn’t notice or would usually be scared of. When introduced to their roles and patterns, we were more interested in spotting everything and observing them than taking pictures and staying far away.
Can parks meet its dual mandate of access and protection? How?
I think that it is possible for parks to provide some access and protect that environment at the same time. What needs to be understood is that there has to exist some diversity in the park. Doing as little as possible to “primp” the park for tourists will allow the park to keep a healthy cycle. For instance, paths should not be cleared and attempts at segregating plant species or animal species should not be made. Also, it is important to limit the numbers per access and the amount of access in general. This will allow time for nature to take her course and preserve the area by herself.
What future would you like o see for the Alberta Tar Sands projects? Continue current path; Stop development entirely; or some modified continuation?
When I was first asked this question, my answer was to definitely choose to stop the development entirely. My answer changed however after I read the book Ethical Oil by Ezra Levant. Although I don’t entirely agree with the points that were made in the book, I was definitely exposed to issues that may be if we stop development in the tar sands completely. The book argues that if we stop production in the tar sands completely, then by our current patterns of consumption, it would only be logical that we would start to rely on the next largest suppliers of oil; all of whom he had pointed out to be highly unethical in practice of human rights and environmental concern. Since reading the book and having further discussions with my classmates, my answer is to continue tar sand productions but with modifications made. There are surprisingly many efforts already made towards the improvement of tar sand productions in considering the environment.
Activity
For my activity, I decided to take the challenge of reconnecting myself with the environment. As such, I took the liberty of going outside with Ben and building a quinzee (or snow cave) in our back yard. The snow mound was already there and because of the weird weather we have been having, the snow is well compacted; we just had to dig a hole in it. We had always wanted to do it but because of pure laziness and fear of the cold, we had always decided against it. The strange thing is that you really can have a lot of fun in the snow if you are prepared for it; i.e. dress warm.