Wednesday, April 6, 2011

Blog 4 - Modern Issues

Selection 12 entitled Ecosystems and Human Wellness was a summary of the findings from the Milleninium Ecosystem Assessment ; a project that started in 2001. It’s main goal was to assess the true costs and benefits effects between human well-being and promoting a sustainable living environment. It argues that the increase in demand for ecosystem “services and products” is the cause for a chaotic and irreversible damage that is being done to the environment. This increase in demand is due to the exponential growth of populations, misplaced interest, improper use or lack of education, and lack of technology or sustainable substitutes. The four main findings are as follows: 1. That over the past 50 years there has been more change to ecosystems than there has been in any other comparable time period in history; 2. The changes did have a positive effect of human well being and economic development but the true costs (to the environment and future ecosystem uses) is growing and still unknown; 3. This degradation may continue and grow substantially worse for the next half of this century; and 4. A change towards sustainability while preserving human well being can be achieved if we incorporate changes in policies, institutions, and practices. This selection also provided four scenarios for possible global future outcomes to show the need for some sort of change now to protect our future.

Reflection
This article was very redundant for me in the beginning. It stated many issues and connections that I feel have been exposed in this class thoroughly before. However, I did find it interesting that this article made a connection between preserving our environment for sustainability and well being and continuing our patterns because our current pursuits are a great positive towards human’s well being. This has never really been brought up before; the issues that we have as a species has been outlined for us and it is great to know, but I always associated the damage we are doing to overconsumption, waste, and just pure slothfulness. It never occurred to me that there are other reasons why we are not making a complete 180 in terms of our consumption patterns; I always thought about the monetary costs.
I was also fairly interested in reading about the four different scenarios and was curious about where the criteria for each scenario came from. I also found that four scenarios was not enough to encompass such an intricate system; we’re talking about Earth’s system and Humanity here!  Regardless, the results were interesting to read.

Selection 31 was an excerpt from Sandra Steingraber’s “Living Downstream: An Ecologist Looks at Cancer and the Environment”. The piece was written in first person point of view and discusses the author’s opinion on the lack of research and willingness to change our behaviours related to the use of cancer inducing chemicals in our products and releasing it into the environment. It provided great details of her knowledge on bladder cancer and the chemicals that are either fully or partially related to the encouragement of cancer in the body. The piece also differentiated between hereditary and environmental causes of cancer. She questions why cancer causing chemicals are allowed to persist in our environment and proposes that we have a right to be learned of the chemicals that are in our every products and how they affect us.

Reflection
I thought this was a great piece for introducing awareness to our lack of knowledge regarding chemicals that are added to our products. The author made it easy to relate and think about the issues as she starts off by telling us a bit about her family and friends; people who are very normal and are all different but all have been affected by cancer. It made the issue of cancer more real when you understand that it could happen to anybody. I like that she made the point that not all cancers are hereditary. A lot of people feel that it could not happen to them if it does not run in the family but the fact of the matter is that environment has a lot to do with whether or not we are the one in two Americans ( or Canadians) who are susceptible to cancer. It’s alarming to think of all the sources of carcinogens, aromatic amines, and other harmful chemicals that we are exposed to because really, who knows for sure what we are exposed to on a daily basis. I keep thinking back to a video we saw in class where the speaker kept mentioning that our pillows keep getting dunked in chemicals (fire retardants) that essentially are neurotoxins. What’s the point? Are we not smart enough to understand that we don’t light our pillows on fire? This can be extrapolated into everything else that contains chemicals. I really do wonder why we have to include such chemicals. It would be great if all manufacturers were subject to listing all the “ingredients” in their products with an explanation as to why it’s needed and how it affects us. Then we can decide for ourselves if it is worth the risk. But at this point, we really have no choice in the matter. Our heads are dunked in these chemicals and we don’t even know what they are or how they can affect us in the long run. There is no avoiding it either. It’s also very sad to know that we do have an understanding of some probable causes of cancer and that we do all these great things towards fighting it (runs, foundation banquets, awareness games, etc.) but we don’t do the most obvious thing to reduce incidence; that is, we can just not use the chemicals that we know for sure are linked to cancer. Isn’t that simple enough?

Selection 32 entitled “Our Stolen Future” by T. Colborn, D. Dumanoski, and J.P. Meyers made a connection between humans and animals in terms of hormones and the disruptive nature of hormone mimics that are present in our environment. The article brought about the findings related to these hormone disruptors and some of its opposing opinions as well. One of the biggest complaints about the findings of the hormone disruptors is that the tests had very high concentrations in the test animals and that the results are unrealistic. The researchers did agree that the large concentration skews important information that could be missed in the lower end of the spectrum but the danger is present regardless of this issue.  

Reflection
The fact that some areas are more at risk for being more exposed to hormone disruptors is really sad. It shows a hierarchy of importance that we place on human lives because really, chemical exposure is not a small matter. It’s also quite scary to know that we have already been exposed to these chemicals for so long already. The damage is done but we are only beginning to learn the extent of it now. I wouldn’t question the link between human and animals in terms of hormone uses. If we rely on animal testing for cosmetics (HORRIBLE! EVIL!) and preliminary drugs, then why would it be so difficult to compare between humans and animals for the hormone inhibitors or mimics. The idea of having unknown substances in our environment and products should be an alarming problem but for some reason it is not. I couldn’t help but feel helpless reading this. I feel injustice but am unable to do anything about it because I don’t know where to begin. Who can we talk to and what can we say? Everything that needs to be known is known but there is no action.

Selection 34 was called “Environmental Justice for All” by Robert D. Bullard. It’s main point is to bring light to the issue of environmental discrimination against minorities and the underprivileged. The issue of minority countries being used as dumping grounds without no flicker of a thought about the consequences that would happen to the local residents was discussed. The article also discussed the origins of a new breed of environmental activists that privy for the minorities and the poor and the introduction of the term ‘Environmental Justice’. The new definition broader term of environment allowed for a movement in environmentalism. The first case that challenged environmental discrimination using civil rights laws was actually one that was taken by the author’s wife, Linda M. Bullard. Afterwards, it went on to detail the events of Warren County that led to the landmark publishing “Toxic Wastes and Race in the U.S.” by the United Church of Christ. To conclude, the article outlined some accomplishments made by the complaints and voice of united activists.

Reflection
This selection was both a bit disturbing and liberating to me. I was glad to see that there were some victories in an endless list of questionable results in terms of environmental changes but at the same time it really bothers me that there is such a discrepancy between the value of life for different races or social classes. Beyond the fact that it is not fair, that no one has the right to determine who has more value, don’t the offenders understand: it will ALWAYS get back to you. In other words, when we destroy the environment, regardless of where it is localized, we are destroying the world. I just don’t understand why no one, in this day and age of all the information that is provided to us (both on paper and through example in the climate change and loss of resources), understands the cyclic nature of ..EVERYTHING. I just don’t get it. How do we still not get that everything has a process in earth and that if we destroy something here it will ultimately affect us everywhere else?

Selection 10 entitled “Life and Death of the Salt Marsh” by John Teal and Mildred Teal was a piece that focused on the environmental impacts of salt marshes. The piece starts off by describing to the reader what it might look like if they stumble upon a salt marsh; it began by describing the salt marsh that is along the eastern coast of North America. At first it sounds beautiful but then it talks about the ugly consequences of the marshes being tampered with; disturbed and dug up or ruined. It talks about how the soil conditions are ruined forcing the marshes to engulf themselves and how it is exposed to toxins and garbage; the image is difficult to bear. Finally, the article closes with some solutions and suggestions. The authors suggest that marshes values are misunderstood; that their values are much higher than what we get by filling them up with garbage; they mention the benefits to fishers and locals around the coast. They suggest that planning should be done on a NATIONAL level to show progress and that planning involves the understanding of the true value that marshes offer to us. 

Reflection
When reading the delicate manner in which the authors described a undisturbed salt marsh I began to think about the many beauties of the world that I have yet to see. I started wondering if there was anything that I wanted to see that may be jeopardized by our actions and choices today. What if my children and children’s children are not able to see the pristine rivers and lakes and fish and camp and just enjoy the beauty of nature that I have growing up and hope to see for all of my life. It’s a shame that we can’t see the value in the beauties that we can’t produce. I liked that the authors pointed out that there isn’t much that we can do if we don’t understand the true value of what we are fighting for. I think that the value that we perceive can build a fire that is much stronger than the one that is made by feeling guilty or sympathy for someone else.

Activity
For my environmental activity, I decided to take a nature walk when I was in Vancouver to see how they differ from Winnipeg in terms of going Green. I quickly saw a difference just by looking out of my hotel window. Every rooftop had an urban farm; if not, they had shrubs, bushes, potted plants. It was amazing to see the amount of green (literally) just from up above. I also noticed that all the hotels and restaurants I stopped by had a green code of ethics; EVERY ONE. I mean, we are getting there (even snails cross the finish line) but it’s amazing how far along Vancouver is. Green is not a new phrase there. On top of the greenery, there has to be mention towards the pedestrian and bike friendly roads. The pedestrian life-style was amazing. It was fashionable to walk! And everyone was on average very fit. I noticed the electrical cords all over downtown and I asked the taxi driver on the way to the airport about it. It turns out that when they can most efficiently do it (only downtown Vancouver; not rural areas) the buses connect to the wiring and turn into hybrids to reduce fossil fuel consumption. How great is that! Anyways, to finish off my walk, I went to talk to one of the ‘artists’ (as he called himself) that was doing some landscaping in the farm. He allowed me to take pictures of his work and told me what happens to most of the plants grown in urban farms. Most can be taken to local stores for sale but at the right time, the farmers themselves will sell the produce fresh! Here are some pictures I took:







Blog Reflection:
What are some of you core values and how do you feel this affects your choices and activities in terms of environment?


I feel that I try to make conscious choices for my daily activities. I know that I do a lot of things that may harm the environment without blinking twice. I'm a pretty big contributor to waste (as was shown in the waste audit). I never thought to think that my actions had a lot more impact than just on my behalf. The fact that we all share the consequences makes it more easy for me to make better choices. I try to reduce my contribution to wastes that can't be recycled or reused and I am more conscious in the choices I make for the products that I use everyday. In terms of food, I think I'm doing ok. It's a lot easier to change or continue making good choices when the benefits are for my own health and body too. The one thing that I have not done is to be more vocal and active. I try to make changes for myself and my family but I haven't expressed my opinions or shared my knowledge on to my friends or beyond. I feel that that would be the next step that I have to take to further my efforts in protecting OUR environment.

รจ  

Tuesday, March 8, 2011

Blog 3: Modern Issues


Selection 29 was an excerpt from Environmental, Energetic, and Economic Comparisons of Organic and Conventional Farming systems by David Pimentel et al. The main concept behind the piece was to discuss the positive influences that techniques used by organic farming could have on conventional farming (i.e. with the use of synthetic fertilizers and pesticides). The piece does so by outlining a 20 year study that has been going on since 1981. The experiment compared and contrasted three different types of crops. One was maintained by conventionally manners with the use of synthetic fertilizers and pesticides and little crop rotation; another was maintained by organic-animal based cropping wherein manure was used for fertilization and mechanical de-weeding was used over chemical; and finally, the third was maintained by organic-legume based cropping which was based on a cash-grain system with no livestock; the latter two both utilized unconventional crop rotation systems. The studies show that although there is a large difference in the beginning, there yields of the conventional crop did not necessarily out-perform the organic-based crops. On average, they were neck-to-neck in yields but on some years, conventional farming did out-yield the organic-based methods. However, the results also showed that the organic-based crops were more resilient to natural occurrences such drought. The water and nutrient retained in the soil was also greater in the organic-based crops; there was also less input of oil and natural gases to maintain the organic-based crops.

Reflection:
When reading Selection 29, I couldn’t help but think about the conversation I had had with a friend of mine. After one of my enviro' classes I had tried to explain the benefits of organic farming to him. Since he loves to play Devil’s Advocate and surely enjoyed hitting a nerve, what resulted was a heated debate that ended on this point: “So we all know that some farmers are already having problems making their bills; if organic based farming and eco-friendly agricultural methods were profitable and more sustainable than conventional farming, why isn’t everyone jumping on the bandwagon?” I didn’t know how to answer this question. If indeed, it is profitable to switch to more sustainable methods of farming, then why isn’t everyone eager to go in this direction? This selection provided me with a logical explanation; the conclusion is that full-on organic farming may not necessarily be logical, but the use of its practices definitely is. How many other areas in our lives have we learned to take only the best of every practice? For example: on a diet? You can still eat good food but know how to make the right choices as well. Why not apply this to agriculture? Sure, use conventional farming, but why not reduce the use of synthetic resources and use crop rotation to do some of that work for you? Saves a lot of money!
Selection 41 was an excerpt from “Ecofeminism” by Maria Miles and Vandana Shiva under the selection called "Women's Indigenous Knowledge and Biodiversity Conservation." As can be shown by the title of the book, this piece relates biodiversity and feminism. The introduction makes the claim that gender and diversity are linked. The lesser value that is placed upon women in most patriarchal societies can be compared to the lesser value that is placed upon biodiversity by developers. In addition, the piece makes the claim that the destruction of biodiversity and the increase of monocultures is symbolic of a capitalist patriarchy and that the irrelevance of women are related. This stems from the belief that women have the expertise in diversity; that it is their knowledge. Women’s knowledge and experience on the farm are extremely valuable, yet, it is not acknowledged. In one of the larger agricultural countries, India, major studies have shown that it is women that are the major producers of food (in regards to value, volume, and hours worked) and have thus developed the knowledge that is detrimental to the preservation of the crops and of diversity. The sad truth is that their work, although as viable as any other in the field, has not been taken seriously. The general view is that women produce their crops through biodiversity whereas corporate men do it through uniformity. To those women, the seed is symbolic of the continuity of life itself. The argument is that corporate men breed seeds that does not produce a reproducing-crop in order to force farmers to go to them to purchase more “seeds” every year. 

Reflection
In all honesty, I didn’t really see the connection that the authors were trying to make between biodiversity and women. Biodiversity is an issue for all of us in order to conserve our livelihoods. I didn’t see the knowledge of biodiversity as pertaining only to those women who work in the fields of India. Biodiversity is in our history and it is only very recently that man has tried to play *BLANK and create his monocultures. I also didn’t find the argument that gender and diversity are linked. I do understand that the issue of gender-inequalities are still valid but it has honestly come a long way; and it just really doesn’t make sense to me to link to two issues. The idea is very vague and far-fetched. However it was very interesting to learn exactly of how the “patenting of life” really works. I sort of understood it before but this little paragraph in the excerpt really sums it up well. Selling seeds that cannot physically and or legally reproduce more seeds. How disgusting is that? The last few paragraphs do make sense in that they tie in the contrasting values of a seed, but again, I feel that the side of preservation of biodiversity is not fought by women alone and that the authors are making too much of a stretch to say that it is.


The piece entitled “Human Domination of Earth’s Ecosystems” by P. Vitousek, H. Mooney, and J. Melillo, was chosen as our selection nine. The main concept behind the piece was that the exponential growth of humans and their resulting dominance over the global ecosystem is leading factor in global climate change and the reduction in biodiversity. The thought behind this is that with a growing population and with their increasing wants, there comes an increase in the resources needed as well.
Land transformation is explained as the result of the use of land to provide goods and services to humans which changes the Earth’s systems and climate; hence by climate change, land transformation is also the primary force behind the loss of biodiversity.
In terms of human impacts on oceans, the amount of impact was said to be harder to quantify but they argue that it isn’t difficult to see that the changes are substantial. In large part, the increase of human inhabitants towards coastal locations have affected the local ecosystem of wetlands and the areas if interaction between see and coast. In addition, the focused fishing of certain marine organisms has led to the unequal dispersing of marine organisms on different trophic levels.
The largest impact of human exponential growth is in the alterations it creates to biogeochemical cycles. Carbon is one of the main contributors to global climate change and with the exponential growth in human population, there can only be more consumption of fossil fuels; and hence the emission of carbons into our atmosphere. Our great increases in the use of water have led to the depletion of our fresh water supplies. Most of the water use goes to agricultural practices which continue to grow in scale due to the increasing demands. In addition to the overuse and waste of our water supplies, the alterations made to any water body (e.g. dams) changes many localized ecosystems as well. Nitrogen is required for the cycle of life; it controls many aspects of carbon storage and species composition. However, due to the fixation of nitrogen into synthetic fertilizers and other means, the scales are being tipped and there are excessive amounts of nitrogen in our cycles and many issues that come along with it (e.g. acid rain, for one).
All this leads to many biotic changes such as the rapid extinction of many species and the rearrangement of biotic systems having new invasive species enter new ecosystems and potentially taking over Hence the authors argue that we have to know and understand these changes. We have to look at reducing the rate at which we alter the earth’s systems, we have to try to increase our understanding of the Earth’s systems, and finally, population growth and resource-use-standards must be managed.

Reflection
Human population growth has been a standing issue for a long time and the debate has always been between stagnating and reducing our growth or re-evaluating our consumptions. To me, the answer is neither one by itself but rather a combination of the two. In western societies, further education and shifts in priority (among other reasons) has delayed the average age of the first pregnancy to later years and decreased the average number of children per household. However, with this decrease in growth rate, we are still among the top contributors of pollutants and consumers of resources. In less developed countries that don’t have the help of contraception and education, growth rates still remain relatively high, yet the consumption is arguably less than or equal to that of western societies. I think the answer to how this is possible is also the path to which we should follow in order to increase sustainability on Earth. 

Sometimes though, I can’t help but wonder if this isn’t just part of some grander cycle that we do not know about. If you think about it, human life in general is relatively young compared to the existence of the universe. Sometimes I can’t help but think that the changes that are occurring can only be slowed down but can never truly be stopped. Has anyone else ever thought about this too? Anyways, that’s very depressing. Regardless of the strength of that argument, I think the focus must still be to at least make life on Earth sustainable for now. There should be more focus on educating both sides of the totem. For the over consumers, maybe if classes such as environmental sciences become mandatory in early stages will help in the next generation’s perspectives and understanding. Having knowledge of the issues that we are affected by everyday but are not exposed to is very enlightening. It allows for a person to take a position one way or the other and become active about it. Not knowing at all is the ultimate loss. For the over producers (of children): maybe some sex education. Lol. I have no idea what can be done to educate people on the importance of reducing our numbers; I’ll leave that opinion to someone else who has more thought in that area.

Activitiy
For my activity, I decided to watch the “Eric Sanderson pictures New York—before the city” video.It was interesting how he spoke of how animals utilize the environment around them to live and enhance their life needs and then how New Yorkers had billboards and he had no idea what they needed them for. It was also very interesting how he ‘geo-referenced” the modern city map with the old topography map and that it didn’t make any sense where everything was. Then he calculated the way in which everything naturally worked on the old topography map, including things such as location of water, slopes, wind direction, animal migration and where it made the most sense for humans to inhabit; very interesting that the indigenous people resided near those areas. It just really makes me wonder why people would go against the naturally easy ways to situate themselves in a manner that is also sustainable. His vision of the future was beautiful to see. The sad part is that I feel that we have the capability to take measures to go down this path but we won’t. A part of me always believes that the changes can be made now so that the results can be seen by our children but that because it is not the most profitable way, we won’t. The problem is that any changes made now will not yield results until a later date, but we are too self-absorbed to see the importance of making the choice.

*If you are interested in the video, it is very interesting and you can watch it
HERE

Blog Reflection
 
QUESTION 1
Consider your food system: what do you like about it? What do you dislike about it? Consider taste, nutrition, cost, equity, and environmental issues surrounding food.

Last year, I moved out of my family home for the first time in my life and moved downtown. I went from living in an eight person household to living in a two person household (+1 Flapjack - he's our pug that thinks he's a boy). The one thing that I truly hate about my food system is in all the waste that we produce. It is honestly a hard task to go from cooking for 8 to only cooking for 2. It is always a conflicting issue for me. I feel like if I am going to waste energy by turning on my large oven then I should cook a large roast to make use of all that energy. But then again, my conflicting dilemma is that I will end up making too much food -- and regardless of how much we say we are going to eat all our leftovers, we just never eat all of it. Another issue with cooking for 2 is to buy for 2. I have a hard time finishing my vegetables before they go bad. Fruits used to be an issue for me until I realised that I could just buy one or two apples instead of a bag (like I used to with my family at home).

Another thing that I really hate is something that is really hard to change. Coming from an ethnic background, I eat a lot of ethnic food that requires a lot of exotic ingredients, which means importing. Take for instance: papaya salad; almost everything in that dish is imported: all the herbs, the papaya, the green mangoes, the sauce; everything. That is something that I just can't change. I guess what I have come to realise is that you can't get rid of all bad habits, you can only try to reduce can't quit and quit the ones you can. Exotic ingredients is my vice.

The things that I do like about my food system is the choices I make while shopping. When I can, I will always choose organic over non-organic, and local over everything else. It's not only the positive impact that it has on the environment and local commerce but also the taste is quite extraordinary. It's pretty sad to think that Ben and I never really knew how great strawberries could taste when they are local and organic. Oh, and not to mention the health benefits! 

All my life I have known someone who is vegetarian but had never considered the idea. My grandma is a Buddihst and has been vegetarian all her life; she cooks some amazing dishes with tofu (I love tofu..weird I know), but it was never really something that my ego wanted to adapt to (sorry, if you don't know this reference, you should really read A New Earth by Eckharte Tolle I just provided you a link to the Wikipedia synopsis). It wasn't to really recently where I found it more important to incorporate more vegetarian dishes into my diet. A friend of mine is vegetarian and he does wonders in the kitchen; really passionate. And so when he brought over his vegetarian lasagna to one of our potlucks, I was sold. He introduced Ben and I to a whole new possibility of vegetarian dishes using different ingredients. We now eat vegetarian for at least one meal a week.
 
QUESTION 2
What role if any should zoos play in conservation/education? Is it ethical to keep animals in zoos? Do you enjoy visiting zoos?

I'm not going to lie and say that going to the zoo is not something that I associate with happy and fun. I do think that going to the zoo sounds like one of the funner things to do to reassociate yourself with nature and spend time with some people you care about. However, everytime I do go to the zoo, I end up feeling really sorry for the animals. If you watch them long enough, you really do see the lost of spark in their eyes. Animals were not meant to be cooped up in artificial environments. As we can see from the recent activity of the Calgary zoo (here is just one incident), it creates unsafe environments and destructive behaviours in the animals. 
 
I do understand the goals behind having a zoo within the city. It allows people a chance to see something they might not ever see otherwise and it allows them to learn and understand the animals and instill value in them which helps to advocate the importance of preserving them but still, it just isn't right. Interpretations of the animal psyche may be misplaced as they are not a true image of what the animal is like in their natural habitat. This leads to falsified data in studies, misunderstandings by the general public, and harm for the species.


Monday, February 14, 2011

Blog 2: Oil and Us

Selection Six was an excerpt from Lynn White (Jr.)’s lecture entitled “The Historical Roots of our Ecological Crisis”. His discussion revolved around the idea that Christianity (among other religions) was being used to exploit nature. His argument is that they all promote the dominance of man over nature and neglect to inform believers of man’s need for nature. He believes that it is in man’s feeling of rightfulness to dominance over nature that has lead to the destruction of the very things we need to exist. White then begins to give examples of where man has exploited nature for his own use with no regard of the destruction that he is causing. He poses that man should recognize the reliance that we all have on nature and to act to preserve it. He also avoids the idea of equality among nature and man because he feels that that will lead to nowhere; rather he suggests that we should reconsider our interpretations of religion and not use it towards the exploitation of nature. He suggests that we try to realize the importance of balance before it is too late.

Selection Four was from Aldo Leopold’s “A Sound County Almanac”. Aldo Leopold was an officer in the U.S. Forest Services in the 1920’s who, upon an epiphany, realizes the importance of every single thing in nature. This excerpt recalls the details leading to his epiphany wherein he sees the death of a Wolf, not for the first time, but for the first time where he realizes that what he did was not right. By seeing the light die in the Wolf’s eyes for the first time and seeing the deterioration of the mountain sides that were overcome by the overpopulation of deer from lack of wolves, he sees the error of mass killing a species and not understanding its role in nature. The rest of the excerpt is a part of Leopold’s explanation on what he believes ethics should encompass. He suggests that we should expand our views of ethics to “include soils, waters, plants, and animals, or collectively: the land…” (page 12 of Thomas Easton’s excerpt in Environmental Studies of Aldo Leopold’s:  A sound Almanac).

Selection 26 was a piece called “Climate Change 2007: The Physical Science Basis” and was generated Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). It was a long piece that gave previous and current projections of climate change based on statistical analysis and extrapolation. The main idea was to outline the reasons for and effects of greenhouse gas emissions. One of the main ideas is that anthropogenic activities are the main reasons behind global warming and the increased rates of global warming. 

More Profit with Less Carbon by Amory B. Lovins was a reading that outlined the benefits of energy conservation that has been highly skewed over the years. He opens with saying that a basic misunderstanding can skew an entire debate on climate change. The idea is that energy conservation and energy efficiency are mistakenly costly to pursue. When considering the benefits and costs to choosing energy efficient methods, the general public mistakenly accounts only for the immediate cost trade-offs; they do not consider the long term benefits of switching over. Lovins continues to prove his point in this reading by giving examples of different countries or institutions that are saving much more money than they have spend upon switching over to energy efficient methods. He also introduces the idea of an energy efficient system, rather than individual pieces that don’t work together. He argues that a system is much more practical and efficient in saving and reducing consumption and that the benefits are there for all of us to share. He raised this argument by example of his own 4,000 square foot home in Colorado. In terms of vehicle energy saving opportunities, he argues that we are in an age now with the technology that allows us to have lighter, more efficient cars, without compromising the crash-safety of our cars. Finally, Lovins closes with an introduction to the benefits of renewable energy.

Selection 16 on Reinventing the Energy System by Christopher Flavin and Seth Dunn discussed the implications of creating an energy system that both fits the needs of the twenty first century and practicality. He takes a look back at when we first switch from infinite to finite resources in Europe in the seventeenth century to make note that whatever route we decide to take must be taken with precaution.  The reading also questions why we chose to go in the direction of using finite resources in the first place; showing the implications that it has on us now was we approach the peak level of such resources. He then goes on to list and explain the different breakthroughs that we have had in recent years (a bit more than the last century or so) such as LED lights, wind power, solar power, fuel-cells, etc. In the last part of the reading the author relates the patters of energy consumption and societal hierarchies claiming that it is strange that the wealthier populous who have the most opportunity to switch to energy efficient methods and savings are adversely the ones who consume and waste the most energy. Finally, he closes with stating that energy should not be taken lightly; instead, it should be valued as a detrimental part of our well being and should not be wasted and neglected.

The main idea behind Selection 28 is in the unsustainable population growth and the unsustainable practices of such a population. The author, Lester Brown, makes reference to how the economic effects of our bad habits went from affecting our local environments to becoming a world issue that everyone is responsible. It requires a shift in thinking that we have not yet achieved. He argues that agricultural changes will be the first sign of un-sustainability. As in, we will realize the destructive path we are on starting with rising food prices. AS it becomes harder and harder to reproduce or replenish our sources,  our value of everyday food sources will rise; along with it, the economic price. This is also consequential to the loss of land and water to supply our growing numbers. Hence, he argues that sustainability is not just an agricultural problem anymore, but rather, a global problem. Changes in environment will affect the reproductive and replenishing processes of our resources (e.g. agricultural food, fisheries, water, etc.). The problem lies in balancing between stabilizing populations and climate.

Reflection

Selection 6 really focused my thoughts on anthropocentricism and how that affects everything around us. I mean the belief that man is important is not an issue to me; it is in the belief that man is important and nothing else is that is ridiculous. I really don’t like the fact that any fact or excerpt (say from the Bible as suggested by White) can be manipulated or interpreted to benefit one ideology.

What caught my attention in White’s excerpt is when he outlines the anthropocentricism around agriculture. I have always thought of agriculture as one of the most revolutionary changes that has happened to man. It has allowed for the growth and development of mankind and has allowed man the option of staying in one location instead of always migrating. I never really thought of it as a selfish means to our existence which neglects the existence of nature around it. It was quite an epiphany for me.

I was most excited to read selection 4; I was really interested in reading Aldo Leopold’s work ever since we were introduced to a quote of his in one of our lectures. I felt that he writes very eloquently and he allows me to envision the issues more personally. I enjoy the fact that he writes in first-person perspective and relates his own experiences to the reader. Personally, I think that it is pretty rare to both preach the issues and admit to the same faults. His story about seeing a Wolf die and lose its fire really touched me. It’s strange to hear a story like that and know that it is true story. I can’t imagine going from being trigger-happy to understanding the value of life in other beings. 

One of the key messages that I picked up from this reading is in how we have put up so many barriers and middlemen in between ourselves and nature. I took note of this because I know that personally, I can feel a lot better about myself if I was not the one committing the “crime”; it doesn’t matter if I am a contributing factor because I don’t feel the impact of actually committing the “crime”. This theory is easily applicable to many aspects of life. When you are rich, you forget what it is like to be poor and you don’t care because it is not your fault. Just the same, anyone can hate the oil-sands and yet we don’t take precautions to reduce and eliminate our uses. I realized in class when we were given the task of discussing the issues and possible solutions for our problem of “Peak Oil”. It was really easy for our group to point out the issues and to point fingers as to where the issue stems from but when we tried to discuss the possible solutions, we couldn’t think of any. We also all agreed that we were guilty of some of the issues we pointed out too. It really just comes to show how difficult it is to change perspectives and old habits.

It’s crazy how the theory of global warming was materialized over a century ago when sciences were just starting to evolve. When reading selection 26, I have to admit, that was the most interesting fact that I read. The reading was really informative as it consisted entirely of statistics and historical mappings of greenhouse emissions and causes but it didn’t offer me any new perspectives on the issues. Like I said before, the issues are fairly outlined and detailed, but it is in the solutions where we seem to lag. This piece did not offer me any new feelings towards global warming and any other environmental issues but rather, it just reinstates the obvious problems. I didn’t like how a lot of the information was also theoretical. The emphasis that was put on the word “likely” did not impress me. I understand that the establishment of a real cause-and-effect is highly unlikely but the emphasis put on such a point to be politically correct really does draw away from the issues; it almost makes me feel that I shouldn’t be believing these facts if the presenters themselves are uncertain of its truth (regardless of how close to the truth their predictions are). The issues were also not related very well to their effects. Global warming due to increased emissions in the atmosphere does not make me feel the immediate need to change. I did not understand that the melting of the ice caps will mean fewer habitats for other species which can force them to encroach upon human-inhabited land. I did not feel that melting of the ice sheets are adding to the problem of polar bear extinction. I did not feel that the warming of ocean waters is creating a loss in many oceanic species which also gives way to issues with our own consumption. In general, I did not feel that being slammed with information and foreboding messages of what generally could be was moving. It was very generic and repetitive. 

Selection 15 which discussed the benefits of reducing our energy consumption and carbon emissions was a great piece. It provided many examples of small changes that could be done to achieve energy efficiency. It was most enjoyable when the author brings in his own home as an example of switching over to more energy efficient methods; using a lot of impressive exact figures to show his point. I really enjoy it when I read a piece that speaks not only about the issues but what we can do about it. This reading really gives readers a hope of changing the exponentially increasing problem of carbon emissions and use of finite resources. The piece was really easy to read and it engages the reader to think about their own consumptions. The author mentioned that five percent of the U.S. energy that is lost is from powering appliances and computers that are already off and made it personal for me; I felt that there was something right there that I could immediately do. I don’t know what it was about the piece exactly that made me feel this way because there are plenty of other arguments that relay a similar message. I guess it’s true regarding our desires for fortune; relating the benefits to the readers in monetary forms can really drive home the point.

Flavin and Dunn make a valid point in their piece: why did we choose to go in the path of a finite resource? Why didn’t we consider the consequences of choosing such a path? Was it because of the scientific breakthroughs and technology at the time that chose our paths for us as they have mentioned? Or is it because no one cares to think about issues that are too far down to their own time? I was really interested in the parts where the authors mentioned the technological advances that we have made already. In particular, I was really interested in their segment regarding fuel-cells. I never realized that we still have issues with efficiently separating hydrogen. I definitely feel strongly about this alternative resource; I think that we are definitely close to perfecting something that is highly beneficial to our health, economy, and environment.

Sustainability of our every growing population has been a major concern for many years. It is crucial that we understand the need for sustainable practices to meet our consumption needs. With a population that is exponentially growing, any bad habits can lead to detrimental consequences. I found Selection 26 to be thought provoking in that it connects the issues with bad agricultural habits to the bad habits that we, as a species, all have. Hearing about how close we are to using up our last bit of fresh water supply and crop-able land is a scary thought to me. It always makes me think of snippets from post-apocalyptic movies wherein the war is not for oil or territory, but for water. Water is the most basic of our needs and yet it is the most important. If we don’t take action to preserve it, how will we be able to secure a future for our descendents?

Blog Reflections (Classroom topics)

Where do your Environmental Ethics lie? Anthropocentric, biocentric, or ecocentric?

I think to say that my beliefs in environmental ethics lies within one area would to filter out a lot of real dilemmas. In honest truth, I would say that I am more biocentric; I am an animal lover and I believe in the humane treatment of all animals (bold statement, I know). This is a new area for me and I am slowly taking steps towards defending that statement. I also am not going to lie and say I like bugs and or creepy crawlies; I don’t. But I do understand the importance of their roles in nature. Although having diversity in flora also means that there would be more creepies, I would not change it. When I took a guided hike in one of the rain forests in Costa Rica, we were fortunate enough to be introduced to an area that has not been fully exploited by tourism yet. The diversity in that forest is amazing. We were shown things that we usually wouldn’t notice or would usually be scared of.  When introduced to their roles and patterns, we were more interested in spotting everything and observing them than taking pictures and staying far away.

Can parks meet its dual mandate of access and protection? How?

I think that it is possible for parks to provide some access and protect that environment at the same time. What needs to be understood is that there has to exist some diversity in the park. Doing as little as possible to “primp” the park for tourists will allow the park to keep a healthy cycle. For instance, paths should not be cleared and attempts at segregating plant species or animal species should not be made. Also, it is important to limit the numbers per access and the amount of access in general. This will allow time for nature to take her course and preserve the area by herself. 

What future would you like o see for the Alberta Tar Sands projects? Continue current path; Stop development entirely; or some modified continuation?

When I was first asked this question, my answer was to definitely choose to stop the development entirely. My answer changed however after I read the book Ethical Oil by Ezra Levant. Although I don’t entirely agree with the points that were made in the book, I was definitely exposed to issues that may be if we stop development in the tar sands completely. The book argues that if we stop production in the tar sands completely, then by our current patterns of consumption, it would only be logical that we would start to rely on the next largest suppliers of oil; all of whom he had pointed out to be highly unethical in practice of human rights and environmental concern. Since reading the book and having further discussions with my classmates, my answer is to continue tar sand productions but with modifications made. There are surprisingly many efforts already made towards the improvement of tar sand productions in considering the environment.

Activity

For my activity, I decided to take the challenge of reconnecting myself with the environment. As such, I took the liberty of going outside with Ben and building a quinzee (or snow cave) in our back yard. The snow mound was already there and because of the weird weather we have been having, the snow is well compacted; we just had to dig a hole in it. We had always wanted to do it but because of pure laziness and fear of the cold, we had always decided against it. The strange thing is that you really can have a lot of fun in the snow if you are prepared for it; i.e. dress warm.

Thursday, January 20, 2011

Blog One: Choices and Consequences

SUMMARY
Selection 42:  Collapse: How Societies Chooses to Fail or Succeed - Jared Diamond
The main idea behind this selection is that the choices that we make today inflict consequences upon us tomorrow. The connection between choices and future consequences need to be made to prevent situations similar to those of fallen civilizations from occurring. In this selection, there are a lot of connections made between past civilizations and our current situation. It seems to stem from the idea of learning for the past and altering our values to reflect this knowledge that we all seem to ignore: that we are very eerily following the same patterns as of those past civilizations that have collapsed.

Selection 38: How Many People Can the Earth Support? - Joel E. Cohen
This selection discussed the issue of determining the carrying capacity of Earth. It contrasts carrying capacity with the different valuations of quality of life that different populations have. The selection uses the example of Easter Island as an analogy for the whole world’s carrying capacity. On the other hand, the selection also tries to establish that carrying capacity is not a simple calculation and it has many variants that may differ in value for different people.

Selection 7: The Tragedy of the commons - Garrett Hardin
The selection opens with trying to define Tragedy of the Commons. It is the idea that the commonly owned resources are doomed for destruction; there is no technical solution. Due to the attitude that humans possess, both anthrocentricism and egocentricism, It would be always be exploited for its benefits to individuals and its losses would be shared by all; hence, it is easier to exploit (pollute) than to not. If this attitude doesn’t change, it can result in the loss of resources and the deterioration of the area, and eventually, the whole world. The article goes about using analogies to explain Tragedy of the commons and some solutions that have been thought of to mediate this issue.

ACTION
For my action challenge I decided to start by going to David Suzuki’s website and reviewing his Nature Challenge. I thoroughly enjoyed what it had to offer. The Nature Challenge is a program that encourages the implementation of “green” in your everyday life.  It has resources to blogs and sites that offer tips on how to go green. The best part about the challenge is the simplicity of it all. There were a lot of options available for you to choose from and it does not have a snooty feel to it. Unfortunately, I have to admit that sometimes it is difficult to want to try something new when you are intimidated by the terminology or are overwhelmed by complexities. Another great thing about the site is that it had a lot of information.  On the Queen of Green blog that was linked on the Nature challenge, I found in one of the later issues, one relating to garburators. It was written by Lindsay Coulter, Queen of Green (the main blogger of the site).

Here is a link to the blog:

I found this one the most interesting because I love using my garburator. I’m actually quite shocked to read about the extent of the damage that it does to the environment. Needless to say, my use of the garburator will most definitely decrease.

To add on a pathetic ending note, I hate to admit how much a brand can affect my interest (not for clothing necessarily, but David Susuki is very impressive) and I felt more of an interest towards what was being said and the challenge that was put forth because it was endorsed by Dr. Suzuki.

REFLECTION
When reading Selection 42, I realized that I never really actually noticed the idea that civilizations can’t just disappear. What happened to cause the downfall? What happens to the inhabitants? Where have they all gone? Did they all die? If they did not all die, where do their ancestors reside? Who makes the decision and what is the defining characteristic for absolute defeat: the collapse of the civilization? Was it only due to the loss of natural resources that caused the collapse? Did they have the same questions and concerns that we do today? I was particularly interested in the answers to these questions as it made me think of my recent visit to Crete, Greece where I was introduced to Minoan history and visited the Palace of Knossos.  The structure that remains today is amazing and really does make you think about life back in the time of the Minoans. How can so great a structure just be abandoned? What happened to cause the abandonment of their main trade centre (or political, or religious; still up for debate) and the end of one of the longest lasting and largest civilizations of the Bronze Age? Did they understand that the choices they made back then would eventually lead to this?

Here is a picture I took when we visited the Palace of Knossos in 2009; this is in one of the smaller lower level rooms.


It is strange to me that we can look at past examples and mock the fact that they choose their own fate with their actions and yet we are following the same pattern. Population growth leads to an increase in agricultural rates, which leads to unsustainable practices which lead to environmental damage and loss of resources. It is also very frightening to think that once the peak is reached, history shows that deterioration  occurs very rapidly because, as stated in our lectures, we have reached (if not surpassed) the peak of our fossil fuel resource.

The selection mentions that the worst case scenario for deteriorating civilizations is that the population would have to emigrate or die. When we reach this point, what will we do?  If the Earth dies, where would we emigrate to? Are we counting on being able to substitute our depleting resources? This idea made me think of recent news in the media about genetically engineered salmon cultivated for consumption. Some resources just aren’t substitutable, and for those resources, what will we do?

If anyone is interested, this is a good summary of the situation I stumbled upon; just follow the link.  

In Selection 7’s explanation of the “Tragedy of the Commons” I felt there was a flaw in the behavior of the herdsman.  They explained the term by example with herdsman sharing a pasture. When social stability exists, I agree that the next logical behavior would be for the herdsman to want to begin to benefit themselves personally. However, the point at which I disagree is in the explanation of the herdsmen’s decisions to add more and more animals to his herd. The selection explains that the herdsman would personally gain by adding an animal and that a negative factor of, let’s say, equivalent magnitude is shared by all and is therefore only a fraction of the cost to the herdsman. This means that when given the decision, the herdsman would always choose to benefit himself at the cost of others. However, the selection does not acknowledge that there may be some who can oversee the immediate gains and look further down to the long term effects of his decision. 

Our modern world is more exposed to the long term issues of decision making and hence, this should be able to alter at least one persons’ decision to choose for the betterment of the whole. I feel that there needs to be some updating regarding the tragedy of the commons. The exposure and education is there and so the “right” choices should be made, but they are not. Maybe the issue is not in the lack of knowledge of future losses being hindered by current personal gains, but maybe the issue should be to figure out a method to regulate the “making the right decisions”. It is not the ability of persons to make the right decision that is the issue; it is the adherence to making the right decision that should be focused on. This brought about ideas of quantifying regulation. I never really gave much thought to the idea that it is hard to measure the physical quantity of pollution emitted by individuals in terms of in water and air.

I enjoyed the idea of mutual coercion that the author mentions. It reflects on my thought that the focus of attacking the issues should be to regulate proper decision making that benefits the majority; e.g. regulate consumer use of environmentally harmful products by taxing over consumption or emitting.

On another note from Selection 7, it mentions that in any way that we win the game, it involves in some sense, the abandonment of the game. This makes me think of how often we are misguided in what is right and what is wrong in terms of decision making that affects the environment. If we don’t understand it, then it is easier to not play the game at all; i.e. if we do not understand the true issues, we cannot try to satisfy the solution; if we do not have a satisfactory solution to implement, then it is easier to not be concerned at all. This is difficult in that it is much easier to classify a problem as having “no technical solution” than to actively seek a solution or to curb our appetites (i.e. the use of natural resources). Currently, it seems that it is easy to say that we are environmentally conscious to overcome our guilt of not truly being so. However, the consciousness only extends as far as we allow it and most definitely, we have not allowed ourselves to be responsible when it means a change in our comforts. It is sad to think that we think of “winning” as only a means of benefiting ourselves and not our population collectively. This creates unfair privileges and it rewards those non players while costing us all.

Introductions Required

Hi All,

Just a fair warning, this is not really a public blog. Well it is, but it isn't. I am starting this blog to meet requirements for my environmental sciences class but hey, I'll admit it: it's fun to be egotistical sometimes and feel like you are the voice of reason for anyone who's interested.

So, for anyone who is interested, my name is Tran. I am an Alumni of the Faculty of Commerce from the University of REALLYNOTRELAVANT.  After a year of working in the finance industry, I found that it drained my spirit (and I feel I am a free spirit) and decided to high tail it out. I decided to go back to school and go into Educations. Long story short, I tried an environmental sciences course and really enjoyed it and so I am in my second semester of study in this area.

This is how the blogs work:

We are required to read selected readings from the text Environmental studies (Third Edition) by Thomas Easton. Following that we are to write the blog in the form of a summary and a reflection. We are also required to take one of the action challenges as posed by the professor and reflect upon it. For the next following weeks the blogs will take this form and will be pulling from this text (unless otherwise stated). The information and ideas most likely have been around for awhile and are nothing new, but my personal reflections will be.

Hope you follow!

msnguyen