Wednesday, April 6, 2011

Blog 4 - Modern Issues

Selection 12 entitled Ecosystems and Human Wellness was a summary of the findings from the Milleninium Ecosystem Assessment ; a project that started in 2001. It’s main goal was to assess the true costs and benefits effects between human well-being and promoting a sustainable living environment. It argues that the increase in demand for ecosystem “services and products” is the cause for a chaotic and irreversible damage that is being done to the environment. This increase in demand is due to the exponential growth of populations, misplaced interest, improper use or lack of education, and lack of technology or sustainable substitutes. The four main findings are as follows: 1. That over the past 50 years there has been more change to ecosystems than there has been in any other comparable time period in history; 2. The changes did have a positive effect of human well being and economic development but the true costs (to the environment and future ecosystem uses) is growing and still unknown; 3. This degradation may continue and grow substantially worse for the next half of this century; and 4. A change towards sustainability while preserving human well being can be achieved if we incorporate changes in policies, institutions, and practices. This selection also provided four scenarios for possible global future outcomes to show the need for some sort of change now to protect our future.

Reflection
This article was very redundant for me in the beginning. It stated many issues and connections that I feel have been exposed in this class thoroughly before. However, I did find it interesting that this article made a connection between preserving our environment for sustainability and well being and continuing our patterns because our current pursuits are a great positive towards human’s well being. This has never really been brought up before; the issues that we have as a species has been outlined for us and it is great to know, but I always associated the damage we are doing to overconsumption, waste, and just pure slothfulness. It never occurred to me that there are other reasons why we are not making a complete 180 in terms of our consumption patterns; I always thought about the monetary costs.
I was also fairly interested in reading about the four different scenarios and was curious about where the criteria for each scenario came from. I also found that four scenarios was not enough to encompass such an intricate system; we’re talking about Earth’s system and Humanity here!  Regardless, the results were interesting to read.

Selection 31 was an excerpt from Sandra Steingraber’s “Living Downstream: An Ecologist Looks at Cancer and the Environment”. The piece was written in first person point of view and discusses the author’s opinion on the lack of research and willingness to change our behaviours related to the use of cancer inducing chemicals in our products and releasing it into the environment. It provided great details of her knowledge on bladder cancer and the chemicals that are either fully or partially related to the encouragement of cancer in the body. The piece also differentiated between hereditary and environmental causes of cancer. She questions why cancer causing chemicals are allowed to persist in our environment and proposes that we have a right to be learned of the chemicals that are in our every products and how they affect us.

Reflection
I thought this was a great piece for introducing awareness to our lack of knowledge regarding chemicals that are added to our products. The author made it easy to relate and think about the issues as she starts off by telling us a bit about her family and friends; people who are very normal and are all different but all have been affected by cancer. It made the issue of cancer more real when you understand that it could happen to anybody. I like that she made the point that not all cancers are hereditary. A lot of people feel that it could not happen to them if it does not run in the family but the fact of the matter is that environment has a lot to do with whether or not we are the one in two Americans ( or Canadians) who are susceptible to cancer. It’s alarming to think of all the sources of carcinogens, aromatic amines, and other harmful chemicals that we are exposed to because really, who knows for sure what we are exposed to on a daily basis. I keep thinking back to a video we saw in class where the speaker kept mentioning that our pillows keep getting dunked in chemicals (fire retardants) that essentially are neurotoxins. What’s the point? Are we not smart enough to understand that we don’t light our pillows on fire? This can be extrapolated into everything else that contains chemicals. I really do wonder why we have to include such chemicals. It would be great if all manufacturers were subject to listing all the “ingredients” in their products with an explanation as to why it’s needed and how it affects us. Then we can decide for ourselves if it is worth the risk. But at this point, we really have no choice in the matter. Our heads are dunked in these chemicals and we don’t even know what they are or how they can affect us in the long run. There is no avoiding it either. It’s also very sad to know that we do have an understanding of some probable causes of cancer and that we do all these great things towards fighting it (runs, foundation banquets, awareness games, etc.) but we don’t do the most obvious thing to reduce incidence; that is, we can just not use the chemicals that we know for sure are linked to cancer. Isn’t that simple enough?

Selection 32 entitled “Our Stolen Future” by T. Colborn, D. Dumanoski, and J.P. Meyers made a connection between humans and animals in terms of hormones and the disruptive nature of hormone mimics that are present in our environment. The article brought about the findings related to these hormone disruptors and some of its opposing opinions as well. One of the biggest complaints about the findings of the hormone disruptors is that the tests had very high concentrations in the test animals and that the results are unrealistic. The researchers did agree that the large concentration skews important information that could be missed in the lower end of the spectrum but the danger is present regardless of this issue.  

Reflection
The fact that some areas are more at risk for being more exposed to hormone disruptors is really sad. It shows a hierarchy of importance that we place on human lives because really, chemical exposure is not a small matter. It’s also quite scary to know that we have already been exposed to these chemicals for so long already. The damage is done but we are only beginning to learn the extent of it now. I wouldn’t question the link between human and animals in terms of hormone uses. If we rely on animal testing for cosmetics (HORRIBLE! EVIL!) and preliminary drugs, then why would it be so difficult to compare between humans and animals for the hormone inhibitors or mimics. The idea of having unknown substances in our environment and products should be an alarming problem but for some reason it is not. I couldn’t help but feel helpless reading this. I feel injustice but am unable to do anything about it because I don’t know where to begin. Who can we talk to and what can we say? Everything that needs to be known is known but there is no action.

Selection 34 was called “Environmental Justice for All” by Robert D. Bullard. It’s main point is to bring light to the issue of environmental discrimination against minorities and the underprivileged. The issue of minority countries being used as dumping grounds without no flicker of a thought about the consequences that would happen to the local residents was discussed. The article also discussed the origins of a new breed of environmental activists that privy for the minorities and the poor and the introduction of the term ‘Environmental Justice’. The new definition broader term of environment allowed for a movement in environmentalism. The first case that challenged environmental discrimination using civil rights laws was actually one that was taken by the author’s wife, Linda M. Bullard. Afterwards, it went on to detail the events of Warren County that led to the landmark publishing “Toxic Wastes and Race in the U.S.” by the United Church of Christ. To conclude, the article outlined some accomplishments made by the complaints and voice of united activists.

Reflection
This selection was both a bit disturbing and liberating to me. I was glad to see that there were some victories in an endless list of questionable results in terms of environmental changes but at the same time it really bothers me that there is such a discrepancy between the value of life for different races or social classes. Beyond the fact that it is not fair, that no one has the right to determine who has more value, don’t the offenders understand: it will ALWAYS get back to you. In other words, when we destroy the environment, regardless of where it is localized, we are destroying the world. I just don’t understand why no one, in this day and age of all the information that is provided to us (both on paper and through example in the climate change and loss of resources), understands the cyclic nature of ..EVERYTHING. I just don’t get it. How do we still not get that everything has a process in earth and that if we destroy something here it will ultimately affect us everywhere else?

Selection 10 entitled “Life and Death of the Salt Marsh” by John Teal and Mildred Teal was a piece that focused on the environmental impacts of salt marshes. The piece starts off by describing to the reader what it might look like if they stumble upon a salt marsh; it began by describing the salt marsh that is along the eastern coast of North America. At first it sounds beautiful but then it talks about the ugly consequences of the marshes being tampered with; disturbed and dug up or ruined. It talks about how the soil conditions are ruined forcing the marshes to engulf themselves and how it is exposed to toxins and garbage; the image is difficult to bear. Finally, the article closes with some solutions and suggestions. The authors suggest that marshes values are misunderstood; that their values are much higher than what we get by filling them up with garbage; they mention the benefits to fishers and locals around the coast. They suggest that planning should be done on a NATIONAL level to show progress and that planning involves the understanding of the true value that marshes offer to us. 

Reflection
When reading the delicate manner in which the authors described a undisturbed salt marsh I began to think about the many beauties of the world that I have yet to see. I started wondering if there was anything that I wanted to see that may be jeopardized by our actions and choices today. What if my children and children’s children are not able to see the pristine rivers and lakes and fish and camp and just enjoy the beauty of nature that I have growing up and hope to see for all of my life. It’s a shame that we can’t see the value in the beauties that we can’t produce. I liked that the authors pointed out that there isn’t much that we can do if we don’t understand the true value of what we are fighting for. I think that the value that we perceive can build a fire that is much stronger than the one that is made by feeling guilty or sympathy for someone else.

Activity
For my environmental activity, I decided to take a nature walk when I was in Vancouver to see how they differ from Winnipeg in terms of going Green. I quickly saw a difference just by looking out of my hotel window. Every rooftop had an urban farm; if not, they had shrubs, bushes, potted plants. It was amazing to see the amount of green (literally) just from up above. I also noticed that all the hotels and restaurants I stopped by had a green code of ethics; EVERY ONE. I mean, we are getting there (even snails cross the finish line) but it’s amazing how far along Vancouver is. Green is not a new phrase there. On top of the greenery, there has to be mention towards the pedestrian and bike friendly roads. The pedestrian life-style was amazing. It was fashionable to walk! And everyone was on average very fit. I noticed the electrical cords all over downtown and I asked the taxi driver on the way to the airport about it. It turns out that when they can most efficiently do it (only downtown Vancouver; not rural areas) the buses connect to the wiring and turn into hybrids to reduce fossil fuel consumption. How great is that! Anyways, to finish off my walk, I went to talk to one of the ‘artists’ (as he called himself) that was doing some landscaping in the farm. He allowed me to take pictures of his work and told me what happens to most of the plants grown in urban farms. Most can be taken to local stores for sale but at the right time, the farmers themselves will sell the produce fresh! Here are some pictures I took:







Blog Reflection:
What are some of you core values and how do you feel this affects your choices and activities in terms of environment?


I feel that I try to make conscious choices for my daily activities. I know that I do a lot of things that may harm the environment without blinking twice. I'm a pretty big contributor to waste (as was shown in the waste audit). I never thought to think that my actions had a lot more impact than just on my behalf. The fact that we all share the consequences makes it more easy for me to make better choices. I try to reduce my contribution to wastes that can't be recycled or reused and I am more conscious in the choices I make for the products that I use everyday. In terms of food, I think I'm doing ok. It's a lot easier to change or continue making good choices when the benefits are for my own health and body too. The one thing that I have not done is to be more vocal and active. I try to make changes for myself and my family but I haven't expressed my opinions or shared my knowledge on to my friends or beyond. I feel that that would be the next step that I have to take to further my efforts in protecting OUR environment.

รจ