Tuesday, March 8, 2011

Blog 3: Modern Issues


Selection 29 was an excerpt from Environmental, Energetic, and Economic Comparisons of Organic and Conventional Farming systems by David Pimentel et al. The main concept behind the piece was to discuss the positive influences that techniques used by organic farming could have on conventional farming (i.e. with the use of synthetic fertilizers and pesticides). The piece does so by outlining a 20 year study that has been going on since 1981. The experiment compared and contrasted three different types of crops. One was maintained by conventionally manners with the use of synthetic fertilizers and pesticides and little crop rotation; another was maintained by organic-animal based cropping wherein manure was used for fertilization and mechanical de-weeding was used over chemical; and finally, the third was maintained by organic-legume based cropping which was based on a cash-grain system with no livestock; the latter two both utilized unconventional crop rotation systems. The studies show that although there is a large difference in the beginning, there yields of the conventional crop did not necessarily out-perform the organic-based crops. On average, they were neck-to-neck in yields but on some years, conventional farming did out-yield the organic-based methods. However, the results also showed that the organic-based crops were more resilient to natural occurrences such drought. The water and nutrient retained in the soil was also greater in the organic-based crops; there was also less input of oil and natural gases to maintain the organic-based crops.

Reflection:
When reading Selection 29, I couldn’t help but think about the conversation I had had with a friend of mine. After one of my enviro' classes I had tried to explain the benefits of organic farming to him. Since he loves to play Devil’s Advocate and surely enjoyed hitting a nerve, what resulted was a heated debate that ended on this point: “So we all know that some farmers are already having problems making their bills; if organic based farming and eco-friendly agricultural methods were profitable and more sustainable than conventional farming, why isn’t everyone jumping on the bandwagon?” I didn’t know how to answer this question. If indeed, it is profitable to switch to more sustainable methods of farming, then why isn’t everyone eager to go in this direction? This selection provided me with a logical explanation; the conclusion is that full-on organic farming may not necessarily be logical, but the use of its practices definitely is. How many other areas in our lives have we learned to take only the best of every practice? For example: on a diet? You can still eat good food but know how to make the right choices as well. Why not apply this to agriculture? Sure, use conventional farming, but why not reduce the use of synthetic resources and use crop rotation to do some of that work for you? Saves a lot of money!
Selection 41 was an excerpt from “Ecofeminism” by Maria Miles and Vandana Shiva under the selection called "Women's Indigenous Knowledge and Biodiversity Conservation." As can be shown by the title of the book, this piece relates biodiversity and feminism. The introduction makes the claim that gender and diversity are linked. The lesser value that is placed upon women in most patriarchal societies can be compared to the lesser value that is placed upon biodiversity by developers. In addition, the piece makes the claim that the destruction of biodiversity and the increase of monocultures is symbolic of a capitalist patriarchy and that the irrelevance of women are related. This stems from the belief that women have the expertise in diversity; that it is their knowledge. Women’s knowledge and experience on the farm are extremely valuable, yet, it is not acknowledged. In one of the larger agricultural countries, India, major studies have shown that it is women that are the major producers of food (in regards to value, volume, and hours worked) and have thus developed the knowledge that is detrimental to the preservation of the crops and of diversity. The sad truth is that their work, although as viable as any other in the field, has not been taken seriously. The general view is that women produce their crops through biodiversity whereas corporate men do it through uniformity. To those women, the seed is symbolic of the continuity of life itself. The argument is that corporate men breed seeds that does not produce a reproducing-crop in order to force farmers to go to them to purchase more “seeds” every year. 

Reflection
In all honesty, I didn’t really see the connection that the authors were trying to make between biodiversity and women. Biodiversity is an issue for all of us in order to conserve our livelihoods. I didn’t see the knowledge of biodiversity as pertaining only to those women who work in the fields of India. Biodiversity is in our history and it is only very recently that man has tried to play *BLANK and create his monocultures. I also didn’t find the argument that gender and diversity are linked. I do understand that the issue of gender-inequalities are still valid but it has honestly come a long way; and it just really doesn’t make sense to me to link to two issues. The idea is very vague and far-fetched. However it was very interesting to learn exactly of how the “patenting of life” really works. I sort of understood it before but this little paragraph in the excerpt really sums it up well. Selling seeds that cannot physically and or legally reproduce more seeds. How disgusting is that? The last few paragraphs do make sense in that they tie in the contrasting values of a seed, but again, I feel that the side of preservation of biodiversity is not fought by women alone and that the authors are making too much of a stretch to say that it is.


The piece entitled “Human Domination of Earth’s Ecosystems” by P. Vitousek, H. Mooney, and J. Melillo, was chosen as our selection nine. The main concept behind the piece was that the exponential growth of humans and their resulting dominance over the global ecosystem is leading factor in global climate change and the reduction in biodiversity. The thought behind this is that with a growing population and with their increasing wants, there comes an increase in the resources needed as well.
Land transformation is explained as the result of the use of land to provide goods and services to humans which changes the Earth’s systems and climate; hence by climate change, land transformation is also the primary force behind the loss of biodiversity.
In terms of human impacts on oceans, the amount of impact was said to be harder to quantify but they argue that it isn’t difficult to see that the changes are substantial. In large part, the increase of human inhabitants towards coastal locations have affected the local ecosystem of wetlands and the areas if interaction between see and coast. In addition, the focused fishing of certain marine organisms has led to the unequal dispersing of marine organisms on different trophic levels.
The largest impact of human exponential growth is in the alterations it creates to biogeochemical cycles. Carbon is one of the main contributors to global climate change and with the exponential growth in human population, there can only be more consumption of fossil fuels; and hence the emission of carbons into our atmosphere. Our great increases in the use of water have led to the depletion of our fresh water supplies. Most of the water use goes to agricultural practices which continue to grow in scale due to the increasing demands. In addition to the overuse and waste of our water supplies, the alterations made to any water body (e.g. dams) changes many localized ecosystems as well. Nitrogen is required for the cycle of life; it controls many aspects of carbon storage and species composition. However, due to the fixation of nitrogen into synthetic fertilizers and other means, the scales are being tipped and there are excessive amounts of nitrogen in our cycles and many issues that come along with it (e.g. acid rain, for one).
All this leads to many biotic changes such as the rapid extinction of many species and the rearrangement of biotic systems having new invasive species enter new ecosystems and potentially taking over Hence the authors argue that we have to know and understand these changes. We have to look at reducing the rate at which we alter the earth’s systems, we have to try to increase our understanding of the Earth’s systems, and finally, population growth and resource-use-standards must be managed.

Reflection
Human population growth has been a standing issue for a long time and the debate has always been between stagnating and reducing our growth or re-evaluating our consumptions. To me, the answer is neither one by itself but rather a combination of the two. In western societies, further education and shifts in priority (among other reasons) has delayed the average age of the first pregnancy to later years and decreased the average number of children per household. However, with this decrease in growth rate, we are still among the top contributors of pollutants and consumers of resources. In less developed countries that don’t have the help of contraception and education, growth rates still remain relatively high, yet the consumption is arguably less than or equal to that of western societies. I think the answer to how this is possible is also the path to which we should follow in order to increase sustainability on Earth. 

Sometimes though, I can’t help but wonder if this isn’t just part of some grander cycle that we do not know about. If you think about it, human life in general is relatively young compared to the existence of the universe. Sometimes I can’t help but think that the changes that are occurring can only be slowed down but can never truly be stopped. Has anyone else ever thought about this too? Anyways, that’s very depressing. Regardless of the strength of that argument, I think the focus must still be to at least make life on Earth sustainable for now. There should be more focus on educating both sides of the totem. For the over consumers, maybe if classes such as environmental sciences become mandatory in early stages will help in the next generation’s perspectives and understanding. Having knowledge of the issues that we are affected by everyday but are not exposed to is very enlightening. It allows for a person to take a position one way or the other and become active about it. Not knowing at all is the ultimate loss. For the over producers (of children): maybe some sex education. Lol. I have no idea what can be done to educate people on the importance of reducing our numbers; I’ll leave that opinion to someone else who has more thought in that area.

Activitiy
For my activity, I decided to watch the “Eric Sanderson pictures New York—before the city” video.It was interesting how he spoke of how animals utilize the environment around them to live and enhance their life needs and then how New Yorkers had billboards and he had no idea what they needed them for. It was also very interesting how he ‘geo-referenced” the modern city map with the old topography map and that it didn’t make any sense where everything was. Then he calculated the way in which everything naturally worked on the old topography map, including things such as location of water, slopes, wind direction, animal migration and where it made the most sense for humans to inhabit; very interesting that the indigenous people resided near those areas. It just really makes me wonder why people would go against the naturally easy ways to situate themselves in a manner that is also sustainable. His vision of the future was beautiful to see. The sad part is that I feel that we have the capability to take measures to go down this path but we won’t. A part of me always believes that the changes can be made now so that the results can be seen by our children but that because it is not the most profitable way, we won’t. The problem is that any changes made now will not yield results until a later date, but we are too self-absorbed to see the importance of making the choice.

*If you are interested in the video, it is very interesting and you can watch it
HERE

Blog Reflection
 
QUESTION 1
Consider your food system: what do you like about it? What do you dislike about it? Consider taste, nutrition, cost, equity, and environmental issues surrounding food.

Last year, I moved out of my family home for the first time in my life and moved downtown. I went from living in an eight person household to living in a two person household (+1 Flapjack - he's our pug that thinks he's a boy). The one thing that I truly hate about my food system is in all the waste that we produce. It is honestly a hard task to go from cooking for 8 to only cooking for 2. It is always a conflicting issue for me. I feel like if I am going to waste energy by turning on my large oven then I should cook a large roast to make use of all that energy. But then again, my conflicting dilemma is that I will end up making too much food -- and regardless of how much we say we are going to eat all our leftovers, we just never eat all of it. Another issue with cooking for 2 is to buy for 2. I have a hard time finishing my vegetables before they go bad. Fruits used to be an issue for me until I realised that I could just buy one or two apples instead of a bag (like I used to with my family at home).

Another thing that I really hate is something that is really hard to change. Coming from an ethnic background, I eat a lot of ethnic food that requires a lot of exotic ingredients, which means importing. Take for instance: papaya salad; almost everything in that dish is imported: all the herbs, the papaya, the green mangoes, the sauce; everything. That is something that I just can't change. I guess what I have come to realise is that you can't get rid of all bad habits, you can only try to reduce can't quit and quit the ones you can. Exotic ingredients is my vice.

The things that I do like about my food system is the choices I make while shopping. When I can, I will always choose organic over non-organic, and local over everything else. It's not only the positive impact that it has on the environment and local commerce but also the taste is quite extraordinary. It's pretty sad to think that Ben and I never really knew how great strawberries could taste when they are local and organic. Oh, and not to mention the health benefits! 

All my life I have known someone who is vegetarian but had never considered the idea. My grandma is a Buddihst and has been vegetarian all her life; she cooks some amazing dishes with tofu (I love tofu..weird I know), but it was never really something that my ego wanted to adapt to (sorry, if you don't know this reference, you should really read A New Earth by Eckharte Tolle I just provided you a link to the Wikipedia synopsis). It wasn't to really recently where I found it more important to incorporate more vegetarian dishes into my diet. A friend of mine is vegetarian and he does wonders in the kitchen; really passionate. And so when he brought over his vegetarian lasagna to one of our potlucks, I was sold. He introduced Ben and I to a whole new possibility of vegetarian dishes using different ingredients. We now eat vegetarian for at least one meal a week.
 
QUESTION 2
What role if any should zoos play in conservation/education? Is it ethical to keep animals in zoos? Do you enjoy visiting zoos?

I'm not going to lie and say that going to the zoo is not something that I associate with happy and fun. I do think that going to the zoo sounds like one of the funner things to do to reassociate yourself with nature and spend time with some people you care about. However, everytime I do go to the zoo, I end up feeling really sorry for the animals. If you watch them long enough, you really do see the lost of spark in their eyes. Animals were not meant to be cooped up in artificial environments. As we can see from the recent activity of the Calgary zoo (here is just one incident), it creates unsafe environments and destructive behaviours in the animals. 
 
I do understand the goals behind having a zoo within the city. It allows people a chance to see something they might not ever see otherwise and it allows them to learn and understand the animals and instill value in them which helps to advocate the importance of preserving them but still, it just isn't right. Interpretations of the animal psyche may be misplaced as they are not a true image of what the animal is like in their natural habitat. This leads to falsified data in studies, misunderstandings by the general public, and harm for the species.


No comments:

Post a Comment