SUMMARY
Selection 42: Collapse: How Societies Chooses to Fail or Succeed - Jared Diamond
The main idea behind this selection is that the choices that we make today inflict consequences upon us tomorrow. The connection between choices and future consequences need to be made to prevent situations similar to those of fallen civilizations from occurring. In this selection, there are a lot of connections made between past civilizations and our current situation. It seems to stem from the idea of learning for the past and altering our values to reflect this knowledge that we all seem to ignore: that we are very eerily following the same patterns as of those past civilizations that have collapsed.
Selection 38: How Many People Can the Earth Support? - Joel E. Cohen
This selection discussed the issue of determining the carrying capacity of Earth. It contrasts carrying capacity with the different valuations of quality of life that different populations have. The selection uses the example of Easter Island as an analogy for the whole world’s carrying capacity. On the other hand, the selection also tries to establish that carrying capacity is not a simple calculation and it has many variants that may differ in value for different people.
Selection 7: The Tragedy of the commons - Garrett Hardin
The selection opens with trying to define Tragedy of the Commons. It is the idea that the commonly owned resources are doomed for destruction; there is no technical solution. Due to the attitude that humans possess, both anthrocentricism and egocentricism, It would be always be exploited for its benefits to individuals and its losses would be shared by all; hence, it is easier to exploit (pollute) than to not. If this attitude doesn’t change, it can result in the loss of resources and the deterioration of the area, and eventually, the whole world. The article goes about using analogies to explain Tragedy of the commons and some solutions that have been thought of to mediate this issue.
ACTION
For my action challenge I decided to start by going to David Suzuki’s website and reviewing his Nature Challenge. I thoroughly enjoyed what it had to offer. The Nature Challenge is a program that encourages the implementation of “green” in your everyday life. It has resources to blogs and sites that offer tips on how to go green. The best part about the challenge is the simplicity of it all. There were a lot of options available for you to choose from and it does not have a snooty feel to it. Unfortunately, I have to admit that sometimes it is difficult to want to try something new when you are intimidated by the terminology or are overwhelmed by complexities. Another great thing about the site is that it had a lot of information. On the Queen of Green blog that was linked on the Nature challenge, I found in one of the later issues, one relating to garburators. It was written by Lindsay Coulter, Queen of Green (the main blogger of the site).
Here is a link to the blog:
I found this one the most interesting because I love using my garburator. I’m actually quite shocked to read about the extent of the damage that it does to the environment. Needless to say, my use of the garburator will most definitely decrease.
To add on a pathetic ending note, I hate to admit how much a brand can affect my interest (not for clothing necessarily, but David Susuki is very impressive) and I felt more of an interest towards what was being said and the challenge that was put forth because it was endorsed by Dr. Suzuki.
REFLECTION
When reading Selection 42, I realized that I never really actually noticed the idea that civilizations can’t just disappear. What happened to cause the downfall? What happens to the inhabitants? Where have they all gone? Did they all die? If they did not all die, where do their ancestors reside? Who makes the decision and what is the defining characteristic for absolute defeat: the collapse of the civilization? Was it only due to the loss of natural resources that caused the collapse? Did they have the same questions and concerns that we do today? I was particularly interested in the answers to these questions as it made me think of my recent visit to Crete, Greece where I was introduced to Minoan history and visited the Palace of Knossos. The structure that remains today is amazing and really does make you think about life back in the time of the Minoans. How can so great a structure just be abandoned? What happened to cause the abandonment of their main trade centre (or political, or religious; still up for debate) and the end of one of the longest lasting and largest civilizations of the Bronze Age? Did they understand that the choices they made back then would eventually lead to this?
Here is a picture I took when we visited the Palace of Knossos in 2009; this is in one of the smaller lower level rooms.
It is strange to me that we can look at past examples and mock the fact that they choose their own fate with their actions and yet we are following the same pattern. Population growth leads to an increase in agricultural rates, which leads to unsustainable practices which lead to environmental damage and loss of resources. It is also very frightening to think that once the peak is reached, history shows that deterioration occurs very rapidly because, as stated in our lectures, we have reached (if not surpassed) the peak of our fossil fuel resource.
The selection mentions that the worst case scenario for deteriorating civilizations is that the population would have to emigrate or die. When we reach this point, what will we do? If the Earth dies, where would we emigrate to? Are we counting on being able to substitute our depleting resources? This idea made me think of recent news in the media about genetically engineered salmon cultivated for consumption. Some resources just aren’t substitutable, and for those resources, what will we do?
If anyone is interested, this is a good summary of the situation I stumbled upon; just follow the link.
In Selection 7’s explanation of the “Tragedy of the Commons” I felt there was a flaw in the behavior of the herdsman. They explained the term by example with herdsman sharing a pasture. When social stability exists, I agree that the next logical behavior would be for the herdsman to want to begin to benefit themselves personally. However, the point at which I disagree is in the explanation of the herdsmen’s decisions to add more and more animals to his herd. The selection explains that the herdsman would personally gain by adding an animal and that a negative factor of, let’s say, equivalent magnitude is shared by all and is therefore only a fraction of the cost to the herdsman. This means that when given the decision, the herdsman would always choose to benefit himself at the cost of others. However, the selection does not acknowledge that there may be some who can oversee the immediate gains and look further down to the long term effects of his decision.
Our modern world is more exposed to the long term issues of decision making and hence, this should be able to alter at least one persons’ decision to choose for the betterment of the whole. I feel that there needs to be some updating regarding the tragedy of the commons. The exposure and education is there and so the “right” choices should be made, but they are not. Maybe the issue is not in the lack of knowledge of future losses being hindered by current personal gains, but maybe the issue should be to figure out a method to regulate the “making the right decisions”. It is not the ability of persons to make the right decision that is the issue; it is the adherence to making the right decision that should be focused on. This brought about ideas of quantifying regulation. I never really gave much thought to the idea that it is hard to measure the physical quantity of pollution emitted by individuals in terms of in water and air.
I enjoyed the idea of mutual coercion that the author mentions. It reflects on my thought that the focus of attacking the issues should be to regulate proper decision making that benefits the majority; e.g. regulate consumer use of environmentally harmful products by taxing over consumption or emitting.
On another note from Selection 7, it mentions that in any way that we win the game, it involves in some sense, the abandonment of the game. This makes me think of how often we are misguided in what is right and what is wrong in terms of decision making that affects the environment. If we don’t understand it, then it is easier to not play the game at all; i.e. if we do not understand the true issues, we cannot try to satisfy the solution; if we do not have a satisfactory solution to implement, then it is easier to not be concerned at all. This is difficult in that it is much easier to classify a problem as having “no technical solution” than to actively seek a solution or to curb our appetites (i.e. the use of natural resources). Currently, it seems that it is easy to say that we are environmentally conscious to overcome our guilt of not truly being so. However, the consciousness only extends as far as we allow it and most definitely, we have not allowed ourselves to be responsible when it means a change in our comforts. It is sad to think that we think of “winning” as only a means of benefiting ourselves and not our population collectively. This creates unfair privileges and it rewards those non players while costing us all.